Five Thousand Bottles Deep in Old Town
Old Town · Fort Collins · Italian Steakhouse · Visit Website ↗
Reviewed July 1, 2026 · How we review
RagingWine reviewed RARE Italian’s wine program and gave it The Rager — RagingWine’s Vibe-Check rating. How RagingWine reviews wine lists →
Wingman Metrics
The wine list at RARE Italian hits you like a brick of ambition — 5,049 labels at an Italian steakhouse in Fort Collins is not something you see coming. There's a sommelier on staff, the glassware is serious, and the room hums with the kind of energy that makes you want to order something from Piedmont and settle in. This is not your average Colorado pasta joint playing dress-up with a wine list.
The Italian backbone is exactly where it should be: Cordero di Montezemolo Barolo 'Enrico VI' 2019 from Piedmont and Donatella Cinelli Colombini's Brunello Riserva 'Casato Prime Donne' 2018 anchor the prestige end, while the Veneto shows up with a rare Villa Spinosa Recioto Valpolicella Classico 2019 that most restaurants wouldn't bother stocking. The New World has a thoughtful presence too — Zena Crown 'Conifer' Pinot Noir from Eola-Amity Hills and Napanook by Dominus from Yountville give serious drinkers something to chase. The Caiarossa 2016 Super Tuscan blend rounds things out with an ambitious multi-varietal Tuscan that rewards curiosity. Gaps? The list skews toward reds and Italian heavyweights — if you want a deep white wine bench or broader Southern Hemisphere exploration, you'll find it thinner.
Thirty-seven by-the-glass options is a legitimate program — not just the usual suspects clinging to a chalkboard. Prices run $9 to $19 a glass, which is reasonable given the list's ambition, and the Nino Franco 'Rustico' Prosecco Superiore DOCG showing up by the glass is a small win for people who know their Valdobbiadene from their Prosecco DOC. The Villa Spinosa Recioto Valpolicella at $15 a glass is the kind of offering that makes you realize someone actually curated this thing.
Valravn Chardonnay Sonoma County 2022 — $52
At 117% markup it's the least punishing bottle on the list relative to retail — and a Sonoma Chardonnay at this price point drinks well above its station alongside the house-made pastas.
The Bottom Line
RARE Italian is the real deal — a 5,000-label list with sommelier support and the bottles to back it up is genuinely rare at this latitude. The markups sting on the entry-level stuff, but climb the list even a little and you're drinking very well in a room that knows what it's doing.
· Fort Collins · Wine Bar & Small Plates
Taste & Savor punches well above its strip mall zip code — a legit wine bar with knowledgeable staff and a deal-friendly Monday program worth building a night around. We'd send a wine-curious friend here without hesitation, and probably join them.
Small but Thoughtful
Fair
Basic Stemmed
Knowledgeable & Friendly
Active Program
Proper
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.
Villa Spinosa Recioto Valpolicella Classico 2019
Sweet, raisined, and deeply Italian — Recioto is the forgotten ancestor of Amarone and most people walk right past it. At $15 a glass it's one of the most interesting pours on the list and almost nobody orders it.
Benvolio Prosecco Friuli NV
At $36 a bottle it's marked up 176% over a $13 retail wine. There's nothing wrong with the Prosecco itself, but when the Nino Franco 'Rustico' DOCG is sitting right there, paying a premium for grocery-store tier sparkle makes no sense.
Cordero di Montezemolo Barolo 'Enrico VI' 2019 + Dry-aged steak
Nebbiolo's tannin structure and tar-and-roses intensity were basically engineered for aged beef. The 2019 vintage from Montezemolo is still young and grippy enough to cut through the fat of a dry-aged cut without flinching.
· Fort Collins · Urban Winery & Wine Bar
OBC Wine Project is a confident one-producer show — no imported filler, no inflated markups, just Colorado wine priced fairly and poured without pretense. If you're in Fort Collins and want to understand what the state can do with a glass of wine, this is your stop.
Small but Thoughtful
Steal
Basic Stemmed
Willing but Green
Set & Forget
Acceptable
Buckhead · Atlanta · Italian Steakhouse
Luella has the infrastructure for a genuinely good wine program — sommelier on staff, a cuisine that practically demands serious red wine, and a room that sets the right tone. But without a published list and with a Bordeaux-heavy focus at Buckhead prices, there's a real chance you're paying a premium for predictability. Go in with your eyes open, lean on the sommelier, and push them for something beyond the obvious — if they're worth their title, they'll deliver.
Plays It Safe
Steep
Basic Stemmed
Knowledgeable & Friendly
Set & Forget
Proper
· Fayetteville · Italian Steakhouse
Enzo puts in more wine effort than most Italian steakhouses in its zip code — the Nebbiolo and Barbera alone signal someone gave a damn about the Italian half of the concept. Markups lean steep rather than punishing, and having every bottle available by the glass is a real guest-friendly move. If you're in Fayetteville and want a credible glass of wine with your dinner, this is the play.
Small but Thoughtful
Steep
Basic Stemmed
Rotating Cast
Set & Forget
Acceptable
River North · Chicago · Italian Steakhouse
A Tuscan-steakhouse list that does what the room promises: Tuscany and Piedmont reds, a Napa Cabernet block and 33 wines by the glass. Order the Caparzo Rosso di Montalcino (58) if you want the Montalcino name without the Brunello price, or the Prunotto Barolo (145) with the bone-in ribeye, and ask which number on the glass page is the pour. This unrated guide covers the posted drink book, not service, storage or markups.