Abe & Louie's
A Steakhouse List That Actually Earns Its Stripes
Back Bay · Boston · American Steakhouse · Visit Website ↗
Reviewed March 25, 2026
Wingman Metrics
First Impression
Five hundred fifteen bottles is not a wine list — it's a commitment. Abe & Louie's opens with a cellar-deep statement, and the Wine Spectator Award of Excellence on their homepage makes clear they know it. The breadth here is genuinely impressive for a Boston steakhouse, spanning far beyond the expected Napa Cab parade.
Selection Deep Dive
The list leans hard into California — Caymus Special Selection, Darioush, Dominus, Plumpjack — and if that's your wheelhouse, you're going to be very happy. But there's real range underneath the headline names: Spain, Italy, Germany, South America, Australia, and South Africa all show up with enough depth to suggest someone is actually curating this, not just filling slots. The Napa focus can feel heavy if you're hunting for something more esoteric, but the international spread keeps things interesting for those willing to look past the first few pages.
By the Glass
Thirty-nine by-the-glass options is an unusually generous pour program for a steakhouse of this size — most places half-heartedly offer a dozen. The $13–$35 range means you can start light and finish serious without committing to a full bottle. We'd love to see more rotation or a stated seasonal program, but the sheer volume gives you real flexibility.
2018 Plumpjack, Oakville, Napa Valley — $200+
Plumpjack punches above its weight in a lineup that includes Dominus and Darioush — it's often the most approachable and food-friendly of the heavy Napa hitters on this list, and in a steakhouse context, that drinkability on opening is worth something.
2019 Ink Grade, Napa Valley
Most tables at Abe & Louie's are going straight to Caymus or Dominus on name recognition alone. Ink Grade is a smaller-production Napa producer that doesn't get the same spotlight — worth asking your server about it before defaulting to the obvious.
2017 Caymus Special Selection, Napa Valley
Look, Caymus is fine. But you are absolutely paying a steakhouse premium on top of an already-inflated market price for a wine that is extremely easy to find at retail. You can do better with the same money on this very list.
2016 Dominus, Napa Valley + Prime Bone-In Ribeye
Dominus is a Bordeaux-style blend built for patience and red meat. The structure and dark fruit hold their own against the fat and char of a bone-in ribeye without overwhelming it — this is exactly the pairing this wine was designed for.
✔️ The Bottom Line
Abe & Louie's has the bones of a serious wine program — deep cellar, knowledgeable staff, real range across regions — held back mainly by steakhouse-standard markups and a specials program that feels like it was set in 2019 and left alone. Send a friend here for wine? Yes, with the caveat that they should budget accordingly and explore past the Napa headliners.
Comments
Get the Weekly Wingman
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.