Decent pours, wood-fired vibes, no drama
Downtown · New Haven · Modern Rustic Italian · Visit Website ↗
Reviewed July 3, 2026 · How we review
RagingWine reviewed Olives and Oil’s wine program and gave it The Reliable — RagingWine’s Vibe-Check rating. How RagingWine reviews wine lists →
Wingman Metrics
The wine list at Olives and Oil is short, approachable, and built for the crowd that's here for the pizza — not the Barolo. At 27 labels and 18 by-the-glass options, it's a list that wants to keep things moving, not make you think too hard. That's not necessarily a knock; it fits the lively, vintage-Italian room.
The list leans on crowd-friendly American producers — Elouan out of Oregon, Sterling from Napa — with a nod to Italian roots via Carletto's Montepulciano d'Abruzzo and a generic Côtes du Rhône covering the French base. Don't come here expecting a deep Italian regional exploration; the concept promises Italy but the list delivers the American middle market. There are no bottles from Barolo, Brunello, Chianti, or anywhere that would make the Italy connection feel intentional. For a restaurant with this much pasta and pizza on the menu, the lack of even a solid Barbera or Nero d'Avola is a real miss.
Eighteen by-the-glass options is genuinely generous for a list this size, and the $11–$14 price range is reasonable for downtown New Haven. The wine flight is intriguing on paper, but with no listed selection details, it's a bit of a blind date. Rotation appears minimal — this reads like a static list that gets swapped out once in a blue moon, not a program that's actively curated.
Elouan Pinot Noir — $11/glass
Elouan retails around $18 a bottle, so $11 a glass is a fair pour price — not a steal, but not a rip-off either. It's a consistently drinkable Oregon Pinot that punches above its station. For a glass of red with a bowl of pasta, this is your move.
Carletto Montepulciano d'Abruzzo
Most tables here are grabbing the Elouan or Sterling without a second thought. But the Carletto Montepulciano is the only wine on this list that actually belongs in an Italian restaurant — earthy, a little rustic, good acidity. It's a $10 retail bottle that at least feels like it was chosen with the menu in mind.
The Bottom Line
Olives and Oil is a solid neighborhood Italian with a wine list that does its job without breaking a sweat — or breaking new ground. Send a friend here for a fun night out; just tell them to order the Montepulciano and not to expect a deep cellar.
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.
Sterling Cabernet Sauvignon
Sterling Cab retails for $12 a bottle, and you're paying $11 a glass here. That's a 282% markup on a wine that costs less than a sandwich at the deli down the street. There's nothing wrong with Sterling per se, but this is the worst value on the list by a wide margin — you'd essentially be paying full bottle price for one pour.
Carletto Montepulciano d'Abruzzo + Wood-fired pizza
Montepulciano's bright acidity and dark fruit cut right through the char and fat of a wood-fired pizza. It's a classic Italian instinct — red sauce, smoky crust, rustic red wine — and one of the few places on this list where the wine and the kitchen are actually speaking the same language.
Acceptable