Hotel Bar Goes Deep on Fortified Wines
Downtown / Yale · New Haven · New American Hotel Restaurant · Visit Website ↗
Reviewed July 3, 2026 · How we review
RagingWine reviewed Heirloom’s wine program and gave it The Wild Card — RagingWine’s Vibe-Check rating. How RagingWine reviews wine lists →
Wingman Metrics
Walk into Heirloom expecting the usual hotel restaurant wine list — a Cab, a Chard, maybe a Pinot Grigio — and you get a curveball: a tight, 10-label list that's quietly obsessed with fortified and dessert wines. It's unexpected, it's a little eccentric, and honestly, we're here for it. This is not a list built to impress everyone, but it will impress the right person.
Heirloom leans hard into Portugal, with a four-deep Sandeman Tawny Port lineup running from entry-level to a 30 Year, plus a Croft Pink Port and Blandy's 5 Year Madeira rounding out the Iberian corner. They also pull in Hungary's Disznoko Tokaji, France's Banyuls from Domaine La Tour Vieille, and Sicily's Donnafugata Ben Rye — a legitimately excellent passito that most restaurants wouldn't touch. The conventional end of the list (Cab, Chard, sparkling) is listed without producer names, which is a gap that hurts credibility. But the fortified and dessert section is genuinely curated in a way that feels intentional rather than accidental.
All 10 labels are available by the glass, priced between $8 and $30. The $8 entry points cover your basics — Cabernet, Chardonnay, a sparkling — but the real action starts when you move into the fortified tier. Ten BTG options on a 10-label list means nothing is hidden behind a bottle commitment, which we respect.
Sandeman 20 Year Tawny Port — $20
A 20 Year Tawny for $20 a glass is genuinely solid. This is aged, complex, nutty-sweet territory that usually costs more to access by the pour. If you're skipping dessert, order this instead.
Donnafugata Ben Rye
Most people gloss past Pantelleria passito on a wine list, which is a mistake. Ben Rye is one of the benchmark sweet wines of Sicily — intensely aromatic, apricot and honey without being cloying — and at $18 a glass it's an experience most diners at the next table will never have.
The Bottom Line
Heirloom is a hotel restaurant that quietly decided fortified and dessert wines were worth caring about, and that instinct alone makes it worth a detour. Don't come for a deep red wine list — come for the Tawnies, the Ben Rye, and the Madeira, and let the kitchen take care of the rest.
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.
Cabernet (unspecified)
At $8 a glass with no producer name attached, this could be anything from a Central Valley bulk pour to something decent. No transparency, no reason to take the gamble when the rest of the list is more interesting.
Blandy's 5 Years Madeira + New England seafood
Madeira's bright acidity and oxidative character are a natural foil for briny, rich New England seafood. It's an old-school pairing that fell out of fashion for no good reason — Heirloom's menu is a chance to revisit it.
Acceptable