Mateo Bar de Tapas
Spain's full card, played right in Durham
Downtown Durham Β· Durham Β· Spanish Β· Visit Website β
Reviewed April 4, 2026
Wingman Metrics
First Impression
The wine list at Mateo reads like a Spanish regional road trip β Basque coast, Rioja hills, Jerez bodegas, Priorat schist β and it's genuinely exciting to see in a downtown Durham tapas bar. Most restaurants doing 'Spanish' stop at Rioja and call it a day. Mateo doesn't. You notice that immediately.
Selection Deep Dive
The list runs 80-120 bottles and stays almost entirely within Spain, which is a commitment we respect. Rioja is the anchor β Roda, Remelluri, Artadi, Contador β with enough range to satisfy both the Tempranillo curious and the serious collector. RΓas Baixas AlbariΓ±o shows up as a legitimate category, not an afterthought, and the inclusion of Txakoli and Manzanilla Sherry signals someone actually cared about building this list. Priorat gets a nod via Alvaro Palacios's Les Terrasses, which is exactly the right entry-level ambassador for that brutally beautiful region.
By the Glass
With 15-25 pours available by the glass, the BTG program is one of the strongest selling points here β and the price range of $10-$18 keeps things accessible. The Txakoli Ameztoi Rubentis by the glass is a genuine find, and Manzanilla Sherry almost certainly shows up on the pour list, which puts Mateo in rare company for North Carolina. Rotation isn't confirmed as active, but the range suggests more than just the usual suspects.
Remelluri Rioja Reserva 2018 β $48
Retails around $32 and marks up to just $48 β that's one of the fairer Rioja Reserva prices you'll find at a restaurant of this caliber. Remelluri farms biodynamically in Rioja Alavesa and makes wines that punch well above their price point. Order it.
Txakoli Ameztoi Rubentis 2022
Most tables walk right past this and grab an AlbariΓ±o out of habit. Don't. Ameztoi's rosΓ© Txakoli is one of the great food wines in Spain β slightly spritzy, bone dry, with a saline snap that makes everything on this menu taste better. At $16 a glass it's practically free.
Bodegas Roda Rioja Reserva 2019
Roda is a fine wine but at $55 it carries the highest markup percentage on the list β 57% over retail. The Remelluri Reserva sits nearby for $48 and gives you comparable quality with a fairer markup. Roda's reputation is doing a lot of the price work here.
Txakoli Ameztoi Rubentis 2022 + Gambas al ajillo
The high-acid, low-alcohol spritz of the Ameztoi cuts straight through garlic-forward olive oil and lifts the sweetness of the shrimp. It's the coastal Basque pairing for a reason β these two things were basically designed to exist together.
π² The Bottom Line
Mateo is doing something rare for a North Carolina tapas spot β building a wine list that actually reflects the food it's serving, at prices that won't make you wince. If you're in Durham and you want to drink Spanish wine the right way, this is your place.
Comments
Get the Weekly Wingman
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.