Southern comfort, passable wine, no complaints
Downtown · Montgomery · Southern-influenced global brasserie / fusion · Visit Website ↗
Reviewed June 29, 2026 · How we review
RagingWine reviewed Kinsmith’s wine program and gave it The Reliable — RagingWine’s Vibe-Check rating. How RagingWine reviews wine lists →
Wingman Metrics
Walking into Kinsmith — a polished, restored historic space inside the Trilogy Hotel — you expect the wine list to match the room's ambition. It mostly doesn't. What you get is a 27-label list that leans hard on familiar California names and plays it safe at every turn.
The list reads like a greatest-hits of recognizable grocery-store labels: Josh Cellars, Joel Gott, and The Calling anchor the red side, with Faust as the lone reach toward something more serious. There's a lone South African entry — Riebeek Cellars Pinotage — that at least shows someone glanced at a map outside California. The 'global brasserie' branding promises more than the list delivers; you won't find anything from France, Italy, Spain, or anywhere else that might actually challenge a diner. Gaps are wide and obvious.
Twenty-four by-the-glass options sounds impressive until you realize the list is only 27 bottles deep — almost everything is available by the glass, which is convenient but doesn't signal curation so much as simplicity. At $10–$28 a pour, you're paying upscale prices for mid-shelf bottles, so choose carefully. There's no evidence of rotating BTG specials or a chalk board moment.
Riebeek Cellars Pinotage — By the glass
It's the only wine on this list that makes you look twice. Pinotage is underordered everywhere, which means it often gets poured fresh and handled well. At a restaurant full of Gulf seafood and Southern smoke, this earthy, fruit-forward South African red is the most interesting conversation starter on the menu.
Calera Pinot Noir
Calera has been quietly making serious Central Coast Pinot for decades, long before it was fashionable. Most people skip past it toward the louder California names, but it's the most legitimate bottle on the list — and probably the most food-friendly with Kinsmith's lighter seafood-forward dishes.
The Bottom Line
Kinsmith is a beautiful room serving interesting food, and the wine list is the least interesting thing about it. Go for the Gulf seafood, order the Calera or the Pinotage, and keep your expectations calibrated to a solid hotel restaurant rather than a destination wine program.
· Montgomery · Steakhouse & Southern
Itta Bena Montgomery's wine program isn't really a wine program — it's a dessert trolley masquerading as a list. If you're finishing a steak dinner and want a glass of tawny Port or a splash of icewine with something sweet, the Menéres 20 Year might serve you well. But for anything before dessert, skip the wine entirely and order a cocktail.
Grocery Store
Steep
Basic Stemmed
Rotating Cast
Set & Forget
Acceptable
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.
Josh Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon
You can grab this at any gas station in Alabama for around $15. At restaurant markup, you're paying a significant premium for a bottle that has no business being on a menu that charges $20–$35 an entree. Order literally anything else.
Calera Pinot Noir + Gulf seafood special
Calera's Pinot brings enough red fruit brightness and structure to stand up to a rich Gulf fish preparation without steamrolling it — a rare trick for a red wine, and exactly what you want when the kitchen is leaning into shellfish and coastal flavors.
· Montgomery · Tapas & Wine Bar
Taste is doing something genuinely useful for Montgomery's dining scene — a moody, polished wine bar with tapas that invites you to slow down and order another round. We can't speak to specific bottles or pricing until we get the full list in hand, but the concept is right and the atmosphere earns it. If you're in the city for a date night or a special occasion, this is your best wine bar bet. Just go in with calibrated expectations: it's a reliable neighborhood gem, not a destination cellar.
Solid Range
Fair
Basic Stemmed
Willing but Green
Set & Forget
Acceptable