Fortified Wine Freaks Meet Flannel-Clad Savannah Charm
Starland District · Savannah · New American · Visit Website ↗
Updated April 2026
Reviewed by the RagingWine Tasting Desk · February 21, 2026
RagingWine reviewed Cotton & Rye’s wine list and gave it The Wild Card — RagingWine’s Vibe-Check rating. How RagingWine reviews wine lists →
Wingman Metrics
Cotton & Rye hits you with an unusual move: a New American spot in coastal Georgia that's quietly sitting on ports, Sauternes, and Tokaji like they're planning dessert service for wine nerds. The flannel-shirt vibe says casual neighborhood hang, but the list whispers something more curious. This is not your typical Savannah wine program.
The list leans European with a clear fascination for fortified and dessert wines—Taylor Fladgate ports, both ruby and tawny, Château Les Justices Sauternes, and Hétszölö Late Harvest Tokaji all make appearances. That's a deeper cut than most spots this casual attempt, especially the Hungarian inclusion. The Rare Wine Co. Collection suggests someone on staff knows their way around aperitif and digestif culture. We're betting there's a solid Italian contingent and some thoughtful French selections filling out the main list, though the by-the-glass intel remains murky.
Glass pours are the mystery here—no hard data on rotation or count. Given the sommelier presence and the restaurant's attention to wine detail, we're guessing they run 8-12 options that skew approachable with maybe one wild card. If they're pouring any of those dessert wines by the glass, that's a win for anyone not ready to commit to a full bottle of Tokaji with their shrimp and grits.
Taylor Fladgate Fine Ruby Porto — $10
A glass of quality ruby port at Southern restaurant pricing is a steal, especially if you're closing out with something rich or just want to linger
Hétszölö Late Harvest Tokaji
Most people sleep on Hungarian dessert wine, but this is liquid history—honeyed, complex, and way more interesting than the Sauternes everyone defaults to
Château Les Justices Sauternes
Solid producer, but Sauternes in a casual New American spot usually means restaurant markup meeting luxury pricing—the Tokaji offers better value and more conversation
Taylor Fladgate Tawny Porto + Crispy Chicken Wings
Tawny's caramel and spice notes cut through fried chicken fat like magic, and the slight sweetness plays beautifully with any hot sauce situation
The Bottom Line
Cotton & Rye is doing something unexpectedly cool with their wine program—flannel shirts and fortified wines shouldn't work this well together, but they do. Limited intel on the full list keeps this from Rager status, but the effort is clear and the sommelier knows their stuff.
Downtown Savannah · Savannah · Farm to Table, Seasonal
The 1540 Room is a dependable, well-curated list in one of Savannah's most atmospheric dining rooms — you won't find anything to argue with, but you won't find anything to be shocked by either. Send your friends here when they want a great bottle with a great meal and zero drama.
Solid Range
Steep
Basic Stemmed
Willing but Green
Set & Forget
Proper
Historic District · Savannah · Port City Southern
The Grey proves that a curated, adventurous wine list can be just as impressive as a 700-bottle cellar. James Beard Outstanding Chef Mashama Bailey's food demands a wine program that matches its ambition, and the sommelier team delivers — with indigenous varietals, natural wines, and by-the-glass pours you won't find anywhere else in the Southeast. Come for the food, stay for the wine education you didn't know you needed.
Adventurous & Curated
Worth It
Varietal Specific
Sommelier Led
Seasonal Rotation
Proper
Thomas Square · Savannah · Southern
Common Thread is Savannah's rising wine sleeper. Libby Burk is building one of the most interesting sommelier-driven programs in the Southeast — indigenous varietals, natural wines, and a genuine passion for making wine accessible and fun. Not as deep as Common's 710-bottle cathedral, not as famous as The Grey's James Beard pedigree, but arguably the most exciting wine program in town for anyone who wants to learn something new every visit.
Adventurous
Fair
Proper
Sommelier Led
Wine Club & Events
Proper
Historic District · Savannah · Southern American
Common isn't just the best wine program in Savannah — it's one of the best in the Southeast. 710 selections including first-growth Bordeaux verticals, Grand Cru Burgundy, and Napa trophy wines, backed by a three-sommelier team. The $25 corkage fee is fair if you bring something the list doesn't cover, but good luck finding a gap. Plan a trip around this one.
Encyclopedic
Fair
Varietal Specific
Sommelier Team
Rotating
Cellar Proper
Historic District · Savannah · Southern American
Come for the pirate history and the She-Crab soup, but leave wine expectations at the door. This list exists to fill a checkbox, not to enhance your meal—order a cocktail or local beer instead.
Crowd Pleasers
Gouge
Red Flag
Rotating Cast
Set & Forget
Acceptable
Historic District · Savannah · Italian Steakhouse
Pacifico won't change your wine life, but it won't ruin your dinner either. If you're here for the steaks and want a safe Italian red, you'll be fine. Just don't expect value or adventure.
Crowd Pleasers
Steep
Stemless Casual
Willing but Green
Set & Forget
Acceptable
· Lake Geneva · New American
Turf. Kitchen + Tap looks like a solid resort wine program — broad enough geographically to suggest some genuine effort, casual enough in setting that nobody's going to quiz you on your order. We'd feel comfortable sending a friend here for a relaxed dinner with a decent glass of wine, but we'd stop short of calling it a destination for the list itself. Come for the views and the Choriqueso; the wine will take care of itself.
Solid Range
Fair
Basic Stemmed
Willing but Green
Set & Forget
Acceptable
· Sonoma · New American
El Dorado Kitchen isn't trying to be a wine destination, but it's set up squarely in one, and the list reflects that self-awareness. Fair pricing, smart local representation, a few genuinely interesting outliers, and the full list available by the glass make this a reliable stop for a well-poured evening in Sonoma. If you're after a deep cellar or something truly adventurous, look elsewhere — but if you want to drink well without stress, this delivers.
Small but Thoughtful
Fair
Basic Stemmed
Rotating Cast
Set & Forget
Acceptable
· Atlanta · New American
Siren has a wine list that punches above its weight in a few key areas — particularly the by-the-glass whites and the Champagne bottle program — but the markup structure means you're spending real money to access it. If you're the kind of diner who wants to order Furmint on a Tuesday night in Atlanta, this is one of the few places that makes that possible, and that alone earns it a spot on the shortlist.
Solid Range
Steep
Basic Stemmed
Rotating Cast
Set & Forget
Acceptable
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.
List Variety
Markup
Glassware
Staff
Specials & Deals
Storage & Temp
