City Cellar Wine Bar & Grill
California's Greatest Hits, Done Right
Westbury · Westbury · American · Visit Website ↗
Reviewed April 20, 2026
Wingman Metrics
First Impression
Walking in, that floor-to-ceiling glass-fronted wine cellar does the talking before anyone hands you a menu — this place takes wine seriously, or at least wants you to think so. The high ceilings and warm wood give it a steakhouse-adjacent gravitas that suits the California-heavy list perfectly. It's a Long Island corporate park address, but it punches above its zip code.
Selection Deep Dive
The 150-250 bottle list is essentially a curated tour of California's most recognizable names: Caymus, Silver Oak, Jordan, Stag's Leap, Duckhorn, Cakebread, Far Niente, and Opus One all make appearances. If you love Napa Cab and Chardonnay, this is your playground — Wine Spectator handed them an Award of Excellence in 2024 and it's easy to see why. The trade-off is range: don't come looking for Burgundy rabbit holes, Rhône surprises, or anything remotely off the beaten path. What's here is well-chosen and well-stored, but the list plays a very familiar song.
By the Glass
Twenty to thirty-five glass options is genuinely impressive for a restaurant that isn't billing itself as a full wine bar — that's a serious commitment to the pour. Expect Sonoma-Cutrer and Rombauer holding down the Chardonnay side, with Cab pours that rotate through the usual Napa suspects. At $10–$18 a glass, you're not getting gouged, and the range means you can explore without committing to a bottle.
Sonoma-Cutrer Chardonnay — $14
A reliably well-made, food-friendly Chardonnay from the Russian River Ranches that typically retails around $25 a bottle — by-the-glass access at this price point makes it an easy yes.
Stag's Leap Wine Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon
Most people reach for Caymus on autopilot, but Stag's Leap brings more elegance and restraint to the Napa Cab conversation — it's the pick for anyone who wants structure over pure fruit bomb.
Opus One
At whatever they're charging for it here, Opus One is a prestige buy, not a value play — you're paying a significant premium for the label on a list where the dollar-per-enjoyment math works better elsewhere.
Jordan Cabernet Sauvignon + Prime Flat Iron
Jordan's Sonoma Cab has the structure to stand up to beef without overwhelming a leaner cut like flat iron — the wine's restrained tannins and dark fruit complement the char without turning dinner into a tannin arm-wrestling match.
✔️ The Bottom Line
City Cellar is a genuinely good wine destination for anyone who wants approachable California classics in a proper setting at fair prices — it just won't surprise you. Send your Napa-loving friends here with full confidence; adventurous drinkers might want to manage expectations.
Comments
Get the Weekly Wingman
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.