Tre Rivali
Hotel Wine List That Actually Tries
Historic Third Ward · Milwaukee · Italian-Mediterranean · Visit Website ↗
Reviewed March 30, 2026
Wingman Metrics
First Impression
Walking into a Kimpton hotel restaurant, you brace for the usual airport-lounge wine list — safe bottles jacked up to fund the lobby renovation. Tre Rivali mostly defies that expectation. The Mediterranean focus feels intentional, and 150-plus bottles with a sommelier on staff signals someone actually cares about what's in those racks.
Selection Deep Dive
The list leans hard into Italy, California, and France, which fits the kitchen's wood-fired, pasta-forward personality. It's not a deep-cellar situation, but it's a genuinely solid range for a hotel dining room in Milwaukee — you're not just staring at Meiomi and Josh Cellars. The Mediterranean throughline gives the list coherence that a lot of restaurant lists lack. That said, don't expect to go hunting for obscure Etna Rosso or Jura whites — this is curated for a broad audience, and it plays to the crowd more than it challenges it.
By the Glass
Twenty to thirty by-the-glass options is legitimately impressive, and the rotating Wednesday program means the BTG list isn't fully calcified. The Chandon Brut Rosé at $15 a glass is a crowd-pleaser move — it's fine, but at roughly $20 retail per bottle you're paying a steep premium for the pour. Shop smarter and look further down the list.
Chandon Brut Rosé Napa Valley CA — $15/glass
Not a steal by any measure, but if you're splitting bubbles by the glass on a Wednesday half-price night, this drops to a reasonable entry point for a celebratory pour without committing to a full bottle.
Collet Brut Aÿ-Champagne FR
Most tables here are ordering California bubbles and moving on. Collet is a cooperative house out of Aÿ with serious Champagne credentials that flies under the radar — it's not Krug, but it's the real thing. If you're going to pay Champagne prices, at least drink actual Champagne.
Mumm Napa Brut Prestige Napa CA
A $25 retail bottle hitting $60 on the list is a 140% markup on a wine that was never meant to carry that kind of weight. Mumm Napa is a perfectly pleasant party sparkling — it's not a $60 bottle anywhere else on earth. Pass.
Collet Brut Aÿ-Champagne FR + Charcuterie
Salt, fat, acid. The Collet's bright acidity and fine bubbles cut through cured meats and rich charcuterie boards in a way that California bubbles at this price point just don't. It's the move if you're starting with a spread at the bar.
Wednesday — Half-priced bottles from the Mediterranean wine portfolio — rotating selection that includes bold reds, crisp whites, and rosé. Best reason to visit on a weeknight.
✔️ The Bottom Line
Tre Rivali is a hotel wine list doing more than it has to — a real sommelier, a focused Mediterranean selection, and a Wednesday half-price night that makes this genuinely worth a mid-week reservation. Just go in knowing the markups on the bubbles are working hard to cover that Kimpton overhead.
Comments
Get the Weekly Wingman
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.