Italian-Focused, Hits the Expected Notes
· Gilbert · Italian-American · Visit Website ↗
Reviewed October 6, 2026 · How we review
RagingWine reviewed The Sicilian Butcher’s wine program and gave it The Reliable — RagingWine’s Vibe-Check rating. How RagingWine reviews wine lists →
Wingman Metrics
The wine list at The Sicilian Butcher arrives with 27 labels sorted by style — Spumanti, Bianco, Rosato, Rosso — which signals a kitchen-first operation that still made a real effort to back it up with Italian credibility. It's tidy, thematic, and does exactly what you'd expect from a polished Italian-American concept in Gilbert. No wild swings, but no embarrassments either.
The white side leans heavily Italian — Dalia Pinot Grigio from Delle Venezie, the Feudi Di San Gregorio Fiano/Greco Blend DOCG from Campania, and the Poggio Anima Gabriel Pecorino from Abruzzo all show some genuine regional intent beyond the usual suspects. The reds follow suit with a Masi Bonacosta Valpolicella Classico, a Donna Laura Alteo Chianti Classico DOCG, and a Casadei Sogno Mediterraneo Super Tuscan (GSM) that rounds out the peninsula well enough. There's a Cantina Tramin Pinot Nero DOC from Alto Adige that's a legitimately interesting inclusion for a casual Italian-American spot. The weak spots are the bookend crowd-pleasers — Santa Margherita Pinot Grigio and a house Cab labeled Chef Joey — which feel more like obligatory placeholders than thoughtful picks.
Glass pour options aren't broken out separately on the sourced menu, so we can't confirm which of the 27 bottles are available by the glass or at what price. That's a gap worth asking your server about before committing to a bottle.
The Bottom Line
The Sicilian Butcher's wine list is a solid companion to its Italian-American menu — regionally focused, with a few genuinely interesting bottles hiding among the crowd-pleasers. We'd love to see glass pour options made clearer and some pricing transparency, but as a neighborhood Italian concept in Gilbert, the list shows more effort than most. Go in knowing what you want — the Feudi Di San Gregorio or the Tramin Pinot Nero are worth the ask — and you'll drink better than the room expects.
· Gilbert · Seafood
High Tide has leaned so hard into Chardonnay that the wine list feels less like a program and more like a thesis statement nobody asked for. The pricing skews steep relative to what these bottles fetch at retail, and the total absence of any other varietal — no rosé, no Sauvignon Blanc, nothing sparkling — is a real miss for a seafood concept. Grab the Diatom if you're staying, or order a cocktail and save your wine budget for somewhere that tried harder.
Plays It Safe
Steep
Basic Stemmed
Rotating Cast
Set & Forget
Acceptable
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.
· Gilbert · Tasting Menu
Cafe Monarch is a very specific proposition: a tasting menu destination in suburban Arizona that has decided its wine identity is prestige Champagne and cult Napa Cab, full stop. If that's your move — and you've budgeted accordingly — the by-the-glass access to serious bottles like Cristal and Krug Grande Cuvée is genuinely rare. But this is not a list built for the curious drinker looking for discovery or value, and the markups throughout reflect a room that knows its clientele is already sold.
Plays It Safe
Steep
Basic Stemmed
Rotating Cast
Seasonal Rotation
Acceptable
· Hartford · Italian-American
Carbone's Hartford punches above its weight on Italian whites and Champagne — the Greco di Tufo, the Etna Bianco, and the Suavia 'Massifitti' are exactly the kind of picks that separate a real wine list from a prop. Markup runs steep in spots (that Livio Felluga isn't doing anyone favors), and the by-the-glass program leaves some of the best bottles stranded on the bottle-only list. Come for the Italian-American classics, bring a table of four, and split something interesting from the whites.
Solid Range
Steep
Basic Stemmed
Rotating Cast
Set & Forget
Acceptable
North Kansas City · Kansas City · Italian-American
A glass list that fits an Italian menu: 24 wines from $8 to $13, with Barolo, Amarone and Brunello available by the bottle. Start with the $8 Capasoldo Pinot Grigio, or the $13 Banfi Chianti Riserva if you are ordering the Veal Parmigiana, and confirm current prices. This unrated guide covers the posted drinks list, not service, storage or markups.
Old Mill District · Bend · Italian-American
This is a pasta-house list with a wide Italian and Oregon spread: bottles start at $36 and 14 wines come by the glass. Start with the Pastini Rosso at $9.25 for 6oz or the La Quercia Montepulciano at $10, and save Elk Cove ($60) for when you want to splurge on a Willamette Pinot. This unrated guide covers the posted wine list, not service, storage or markups, and the list is undated, so confirm what is available.