Grand Hotel grandeur, surprisingly serious wine list
Mackinac Island · American, French · Visit Website ↗
Updated November 2026
Reviewed April 8, 2026 · How we review
RagingWine reviewed Salle à Manger’s wine program and gave it The Wild Card — RagingWine’s Vibe-Check rating. How RagingWine reviews wine lists →
Wingman Metrics
You're on a car-free island, eating in a Victorian dining room that's been hosting guests since 1887, and the wine list is longer than most city restaurants bother with. That's the first surprise. The second is that it's genuinely well-curated — not a hotel afterthought stuffed with safe brands, but a focused list with real intention behind it.
The list leans hard into California and France, which makes sense given the American-French kitchen, and it earns its Wine Spectator Best of Award of Excellence honestly. You've got Stag's Leap Wine Cellars and Jordan Cabernet anchoring the California side, Chateau Margaux and Louis Jadot covering Bordeaux and Burgundy, and Bollinger keeping Champagne respectable. The Michigan section — headlined by Black Star Farms — is a genuine point of pride and gives the list a local identity that most resort hotels completely skip. Italy shows up but doesn't dominate, and the 300-500 bottle depth means there's real exploration to be done here, even if the price ceiling climbs fast.
Somewhere between 12 and 20 options by the glass, which is a healthy pour program for a destination resort. At $12–$18 a glass, you're paying island prices, but the range should let you move through a few different things across a long dinner. Don't expect the list to rotate aggressively — this feels like a program that gets set at the start of the season and holds steady.
Chateau Ste. Michelle Riesling — $50
In a list where bottles climb fast, this is your smart move — especially against the Great Lakes whitefish. Chateau Ste. Michelle makes genuinely good Riesling at a price that doesn't require a conversation with your accountant.
Black Star Farms
Most guests on a Mackinac Island wine budget reach for California or France. That's their loss. Black Star Farms is a serious Michigan producer making wines worth knowing, and drinking one here, on the island, with lake fish on the plate, is the kind of contextual drinking experience you can't manufacture anywhere else.
The Bottom Line
Salle à Manger earns its Wine Spectator credential — this is a genuinely considered list in a setting that could easily coast on ambiance alone. The markups sting and there's no sommelier pushing you toward the interesting stuff, but if you know what you're looking for, there's real wine to be found here at the top of Lake Huron.
Midtown East · New York · American, French
A Park Avenue restaurant whose posted wine list is a 21-wine glass list. Start with the $18 Leitz Riesling or the $19 Ogier Saint-Joseph. No bottle list is posted online, so ask the restaurant what is available by the bottle. This unrated guide covers the posted glass list, not service, storage or markups.
College Hill · Providence · American, French
A Cabernet-heavy list from autumn 2025, with glass pours from 10 and bottles up to a 450 Opus One. Start with the 10 Château du Petit Thouars Cabernet Franc, or the 16 Fontanafredda Nebbiolo if you want something from Piedmont, and check that the list is still current since it is marked September 2025. This unrated guide covers the posted wine list, not service, storage or markups.
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.
Opus One
It's Opus One — you know what you're getting, and so does the restaurant when they price it. Resort markup on an already-expensive Napa trophy wine means you're paying a significant premium for a bottle that frankly doesn't need Mackinac Island to taste good. Save it for somewhere that treats it with a fairer margin.
Louis Jadot Burgundy + Rack of lamb
Classic French pairing logic holds up here — Jadot's Burgundy has the earthiness and red fruit structure to stand up to lamb without bullying it, and it keeps the dinner feeling as French as the dining room architecture suggests it should.
Dupont Circle · Washington · American, French
Start with the Minuty Prestige rosé at 20 or the Château de Saint-Cosme Syrah at 22 by the glass, and save the Dagueneau for the table that wants a bottle. The glass page is the cheaper way in, with thirteen wines between 20 and 34. The file is linked as 9-26, so confirm today's pours and prices. This unrated guide covers the posted wine list, not service, storage or retail markups.