Skip to main content
RagingWine - Your Wine List Wingman

Sign In

or

No password needed — we'll email you a sign-in link.

A lively sidewalk wine bar patio on a good night out

NY

Water Mill

Sip, swirl, and summer like a Water Mill local.

Explore restaurant wine lists across Water Mill, New York.

RagingWine has reviewed 1 restaurant wine list in Water Mill, NY. RagingWine’s standouts include Calissa.

By the numbers, RagingWine has reviewed 1 restaurant wine list in Water Mill, NY across 1 neighborhood. RagingWine gave 1 of them a top-two Vibe-Check rating — 1 earned The Wild Card.

1

Reviews

0

Ragers

1

Neighborhoods

What are the best restaurant wine lists in Water Mill?

Calissa

Water Mill · Water Mill · Farm to Table, Greek

The Wild Card

Calissa is the Wild Card the Hamptons wine scene didn't know it needed — a Greek-forward list with genuine regional conviction tucked inside what could easily have been just another sceney summer restaurant. Come for the branzino and the Assyrtiko, stay for the discovery that not every Montauk Highway wine list is phoning it in.

Variety

Small but Thoughtful

Markup

Steep

Glassware

Basic Stemmed

Staff

Willing but Green

Specials

Set & Forget

Storage

Acceptable

All 1 Water Mill wine list reviews, A–Z

More wine lists across New York

All New York →
Albany41Amherst1Aurora1Babylon1Beacon1Binghamton1Brewster1Brooklyn6Buffalo11Canandaigua14Cazenovia2Chappaqua1Chester2Cold Spring Harbor1Cooperstown1Corning1East Hampton1East Norwich1East Quogue1East Setauket1Elmont1Fairport1Fayetteville1Garden City1

The best wine lists in Water Mill, in your inbox

New Water Mill wine-list reviews, standout bottles, and half-price wine nights. Every Friday, under 500 words.