The Catbird Seat
Counter-Seat Tasting Menu With A Compact List
Gulch · Nashville · Tasting Menu / Modern American · Visit Website ↗
Reviewed March 2, 2026
Wingman Metrics
First Impression
A 23-label list at a $175 tasting menu spot tells you everything: they're pairing-focused, not browsing-friendly. The sommelier knows these wines cold because they have to—every course needs a match. You're here for the experience, not to BYOB your way through Burgundy.
Selection Deep Dive
The list leans heavily on California, particularly Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir—Bohème English Hill Vineyard and Sea Smoke both show up, which means they're playing in the $60-$90 retail range at minimum. At 23 labels total, this isn't a cellar crawl; it's a curated toolkit for what's coming out of that open kitchen. We're missing intel on Old World presence, but given the tasting menu format and the Pinot focus, expect some Oregon, maybe a token Burgundy, and likely a sparkling option to start. The real question: do they have enough range to handle bluefin tuna with caviar AND grilled cauliflower with cashew purée? Probably, but it's tight.
By the Glass
We don't have hard numbers on glass pours, but at this format and price point, they're almost certainly doing pairing flights rather than a robust by-the-glass program. That's fine—pairing menus are what you want here. If you're ordering a la carte glasses, you're fighting the current. Expect 4-6 options max, likely skewed toward whatever's featured in the pairing rotation that week.
Bohème English Hill Vineyard Pinot Noir — $85
Sonoma Coast Pinot that's structured enough for beef, silky enough for tuna, and won't make you wince at the markup in this setting
Sea Smoke Pinot Noir
Cult-ish Sta. Rita Hills producer that most people skip because they assume it's all hype—but it actually delivers the goods with dense fruit and coastal acidity
Whatever Napa Cab they're charging $200+ for
Tasting menus don't need sledgehammer wines, and you're paying double markup for a bottle that doesn't fit the format
Sea Smoke Pinot Noir + Bearcreek Farm beef strip loin
Sta. Rita Hills Pinot has enough backbone for beef without overpowering the dish—earthy, bright, and just structured enough to handle char
✔️ The Bottom Line
The Catbird Seat isn't trying to be a wine destination—it's a tasting menu theater with a compact, pairing-optimized list. Come for the experience, trust the sommelier, and don't expect deep browsing. Solid, not spectacular.
Comments
Get the Weekly Wingman
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.