Puritan & Company
Grocery-shelf labels hiding a serious back cellar
Inman Square · Boston · Contemporary American · Visit Website ↗
Reviewed March 25, 2026
Wingman Metrics
First Impression
The first page of the wine list reads like a chain restaurant's greatest hits — Meiomi, Kim Crawford, Kendall-Jackson — and your heart sinks a little. Then you flip the page and find Occhipinti, Peter Lauer, and a Cour-Cheverny from Cazin, and suddenly you're paying attention. This list has a split personality, and the good half is genuinely worth your time.
Selection Deep Dive
Underneath the crowd-pleaser veneer, Puritan & Company is quietly running a thoughtful, import-forward bottle list with real range. The Loire Valley shows up twice and earns it — Serge Laloue's Sancerre and Cazin's Cour-Cheverny are exactly the kind of picks you don't expect from a Cambridge neighborhood spot. Sicily gets a nod via Occhipinti's SP68 Bianco, and the German section, anchored by Peter Lauer and J.J. Christoffel, suggests someone here actually cares about Riesling. The California and New World stuff is mostly filler, but it's there for the table that just wants a Malbec and doesn't want to think about it.
By the Glass
The by-the-glass program runs 10-15 options and leans heavily on the accessible end of the list — think Rainstorm Pinot Gris and Joel Gott Sauvignon Blanc rather than anything from Sicily or the Saar. It gets the job done for casual weeknight drinking but doesn't showcase the more interesting bottles hiding in the back half of the list. If you're sitting down for a full dinner, the bottle program is where Puritan actually earns its keep.
Cazin 'Vendanges Manuelles' Cour-Cheverny, Loire — $35
A hand-harvested Romorantin from one of the Loire's most underrated appellations at $35 is a genuine steal. Retail on this is $22, so the markup is the lightest on the list, and the wine itself — mineral, taut, and unlike anything else you'll drink this year — punches well above its price tag.
J.J. Christoffel 'Erdener Treppchen' Spätlese, Mosel
Most tables will walk right past this and order the Kendall-Jackson. Don't. Christoffel's Erdener Treppchen is a classic Mosel Spätlese from one of the great old estates — honeyed peach and slate minerality in equal measure. At $60 it's not cheap, but this is the kind of bottle you'd pay significantly more for at a proper wine bar.
Wycliff Brut Champagne, CA
Wycliff is budget sparkling wine at a not-budget price in a restaurant context. With Moët on the same list, and frankly with the quality of the bottles available elsewhere, there is no scenario where this is the right call. If you want bubbles, spend a few dollars more and get the real thing.
Roark Wine Company Chenin Blanc, Santa Ynez + Smoked bluefish pâté
Chenin Blanc's combination of bright acidity and slight waxy texture is purpose-built for smoky, rich fish spreads. The Roark from Santa Ynez brings enough fruit weight to stand up to the smoke without stepping on the delicate bluefish, and the acidity cuts through the fat in the pâté cleanly. This is the pairing the kitchen probably didn't intend but would absolutely approve of.
🎲 The Bottom Line
Puritan & Company is a better wine destination than its opening lineup suggests — if you know where to look, you'll find a genuinely exciting selection of Old World and domestic bottles at fair markups. Come for the lobster risotto, stay for the Riesling you didn't see coming.
Comments
Get the Weekly Wingman
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.