Mesh Restaurant
Mass Ave's Solid Wine Bet, Especially Sundays
Mass Ave Arts Corridor · Indianapolis · Contemporary American · Visit Website ↗
Reviewed March 21, 2026
Wingman Metrics
First Impression
The list at Mesh lands right where you want it for a night out on Mass Ave — not intimidating, not lazy. You get 80-plus selections organized around California, France, Oregon, and Italy, which covers the major food groups without trying to be everything to everyone. It reads like a list curated by someone who actually eats dinner.
Selection Deep Dive
The four-region anchor makes sense here: California for the crowd, France for the curious, Oregon for the Pinot heads, Italy for anyone who wants something with actual acid at the table. There are no deep-cellar surprises lurking — this isn't that kind of place — but the breadth is real and the producers aren't just grocery-store filler. The fortified wine section is quietly interesting, with Sandeman 20 Year Tawny and Fonseca Bin 27 showing up at prices that suggest someone at Mesh actually likes Port. We'd love to see more by-the-producer depth in the Oregon and Italian sections, but what's here earns its keep.
By the Glass
Fifteen to twenty-five pours by the glass is a serious commitment for a restaurant this size, and Mesh doesn't squander it. The range appears to track the bottle list, hitting the major regions without doubling down on obvious crowd-pleasers only. Rotation isn't aggressive, but it moves enough that regulars won't be stuck with the same six options every visit.
Argyle Bloomhouse Pinot Noir 2022 — $54
Argyle is one of Oregon's most reliable names and the Bloomhouse sits at roughly 20% over retail — basically nothing by restaurant standards. You're getting serious Willamette Pinot at a price that doesn't require a moment of internal negotiation.
Sandeman Tawny 20 Year
At $22 a pour, this is retailing for $40 a bottle — meaning Mesh is practically giving it away. Twenty-year Tawny is a genuinely complex drink that most people skip because they think Port is for Christmas. Order it. Order it at the end of the meal. Don't skip it.
Alexander Valley Merlot 2020
At $54 on the list against a $20 retail price, this one's marked up 170%. Merlot at that price point from Alexander Valley is a fine wine, but you're paying restaurant premium on top of a bottle that shouldn't anchor a $54 ask. Spend the same money on the Argyle and don't look back.
Argyle Bloomhouse Pinot Noir 2022 + Seasonal small plates
Oregon Pinot has the acidity and red-fruit brightness to move across a table of small plates without bullying anything on the plate. It's the right call when you're grazing through a few courses rather than committing to one big protein.
Sunday — Half-priced bottles of wine all night Sunday — makes the Argyle Pinot a near-steal and the fortified pours even more absurd value.
✔️ The Bottom Line
Mesh is a dependable wine program in a city that doesn't always prioritize the list, and Sunday half-price bottles make it genuinely hard to argue with. Come for the food, stay for the Port, and let the Argyle Pinot be your anchor.
Comments
Get the Weekly Wingman
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.