Lorenzo's Trattoria
Solid Italian list, plays it mostly safe
Unknown · Lexington · Italian · Visit Website ↗
Reviewed March 28, 2026
Wingman Metrics
First Impression
The wine list at Lorenzo's arrives looking the part — 80-plus labels, a genuine Italian backbone, and enough California muscle to keep the Napa crowd happy. It reads like a restaurant that actually thought about wine, not just phoned in a distributor special. The Italian regionality is real: Friuli whites, Veneto reds, even a Amarone on the list.
Selection Deep Dive
Italy anchors the list properly, with Friuli represented by both Marco Felluga and Jermann on the Pinot Grigio front — that's a legit dual-producer play that most Italian joints in Lexington wouldn't bother with. Veneto gets some love too, with the L. Righetti Capitel Roari and the Amarone Campagnola 2018 rounding out a credible northeast Italian section. California shows up with Paul Hobbs Crossbarn Cab and Lewis Cellars Chardonnay — these are respectable names, not filler. The gaps are in Tuscany and Piedmont, where the list thins out and you're left wanting more Barolo and Brunello depth.
By the Glass
Glass pour pricing starts around $7-$9 for entry-level whites, which is fair for Lexington. We don't have a confirmed count or full rotation on the by-the-glass program, which itself is a mild red flag — a list this size should be promoting its glass pours more aggressively. If they're rotating thoughtfully, there's real potential here; if it's the same four pours all year, that's a missed opportunity.
L. Righetti Capitel Roari 2017 — $94
Amarone-adjacent Ripasso-style depth from the Veneto at a price that undercuts what you'd normally pay for this kind of concentration. If the markup holds closer to retail than the Gio Pinot Grigio does, this is the bottle to order at Lorenzo's.
Jermann Pinot Grigio 2020
Most people skip right past Pinot Grigio assuming it's boring, and most of the time they're right. Jermann is the exception — this is a Friuli producer making Pinot Grigio that actually has something to say. Don't let the grape's bad reputation talk you out of it.
Gio Pinot Grigio 2021
At a 100% markup on a $15 retail bottle, you're paying $30 for something that drinks exactly like a $15 bottle. With Jermann on the same list, there's no reason to settle here.
Amarone Campagnola 2018 + Braised Ossobuco
Amarone's dried-grape intensity and iron-tinged fruit need something equally substantial. The slow-braised veal shank pulls enough collagen and richness to stand up to it without getting steamrolled. This is the combo you came for.
✔️ The Bottom Line
Lorenzo's is doing more right than most Italian restaurants in Lexington — the Italian regional bones are solid, and a few standout producers lift the list above the crowd. The markup on entry-level pours stings a little, but climb up the list and there's genuine reward.
Comments
Get the Weekly Wingman
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.