Ilili NYC
Lebanese wine country, right on Fifth Avenue
Flatiron/NoMad Β· New York Β· Lebanese Β· Visit Website β
Reviewed March 23, 2026
Wingman Metrics
First Impression
You open a wine list at a Lebanese restaurant in Flatiron and expect the usual suspects β a Sancerre, a California Cab, maybe a token rosΓ©. What you get instead is 470 bottles, a dedicated section of Lebanese producers, and the creeping feeling that you've been underestimating this cuisine's relationship with wine for years. It's a genuine gut-check moment.
Selection Deep Dive
The Lebanese section anchors the whole thing, and it's not a novelty β Chateau Musar alone could justify a visit, and ilili even hosts dedicated Musar wine dinners. Beyond Lebanon, the list pulls from France, Italy, and California with enough depth to satisfy the old-world purists and the new-world explorers at the same table. At 470 selections, there's real range here, and it doesn't feel padded β this list has a point of view. The only gap worth noting is that Eastern Mediterranean coverage beyond Lebanon could go deeper, but that's a stretch complaint given what's already here.
By the Glass
Fifteen to twenty pours by the glass is a healthy number for a list this focused, and the glass program appears to rotate enough that you won't find the same tired Chardonnay every visit. The presence of Lebanese producers by the glass β not just buried in the bottle list β is the differentiator; that's a commitment most restaurants wouldn't bother making. Pour prices are reasonable given the NYC context.
Paul Buisse Cremant de Loire NV β $17
A 68% markup on a solid sparkling wine in Manhattan is practically an act of charity. This is your aperitif opener β bright, food-friendly, and priced like they want you to actually order it.
Ixsir Altitudes White 2018
Most tables walk right past Lebanese whites and reach for the Chablis out of habit. The Ixsir Altitudes is a high-elevation Lebanese white that holds its own against anything French on this list β and at $14 a glass, it's the kind of discovery that makes a dinner memorable.
Laurent Perrier Champagne Brut NV
A hundred percent markup lands it at $25 a glass, which is technically 'fair for NYC Champagne' β but Laurent Perrier Brut is a grocery store splurge bottle dressed up in restaurant clothes. When the Cremant de Loire is right there at $17, this one doesn't earn its keep.
Chateau Musar Red + Lamb chops with garlic sauce
Musar's signature blend of Cabernet, Cinsault, and Carignan has that savory, slightly oxidative character that was basically made to sit next to charred lamb and aggressive garlic. It's a regional handshake β both the wine and the dish come from the same culinary tradition, and it shows.
π² The Bottom Line
Ilili is the rare restaurant where the wine list actually teaches you something β specifically that Lebanon makes serious wine and you've been sleeping on it. With fair markups, a sommelier who clearly cares, and 470 bottles anchored by one of New York's best Lebanese selections, this is absolutely worth a detour.
Comments
Get the Weekly Wingman
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.