Sign In

or

No password needed β€” we'll email you a sign-in link.

πŸ”₯The Rager

Estela

641 Bottles Deep and Still Surprising

SoHo Β· New York Β· Modern American Β· Visit Website β†—

old-world-focusdeep-cellardate-nightsplurge-worthy

Reviewed March 25, 2026

Wingman Metrics

List VarietyDeep & Eclectic
MarkupSteep
GlasswareVarietal Specific
StaffKnowledgeable & Friendly
Specials & DealsSet & Forget
Storage & TempProper

First Impression

Six hundred and forty-one bottles. That's not a wine list β€” that's a statement of intent. Estela's list hits you like a dense, well-organized library where someone has actually read every book on the shelf. This is the kind of program that makes you want to cancel your dinner plans and just sit at the bar working through it page by page.

Selection Deep Dive

France anchors the list, as it should, but there's genuine range across Old World Europe and thoughtful New World representation that doesn't feel like an afterthought. The presence of AndrΓ© Beaufort's Demi-Sec Champagne β€” a grower producer that most restaurants wouldn't touch for fear of confusing their guests β€” signals that whoever built this list is playing for the curious drinker, not the safe one. The Rare Wine Company Boston Bual Madeira is the kind of inclusion that earns credibility: Madeira is chronically underserved at restaurants, and putting it on the list at all shows range and intellectual honesty. The price ceiling of $7,000 tells you there's serious cellar depth, but the floor at $65 means you don't need to be a hedge fund manager to participate.

By the Glass

By-the-glass specifics weren't available to us at time of review, but with a list this size and a sommelier on staff, expect a rotating selection that punches above the usual suspects. At a place like this, ask your server what's open β€” you'll likely get something more interesting than what's printed.

πŸ’°Best Value

AndrΓ© Beaufort Demi-Sec Champagne (Pinot Noir) β€” $65+

Grower Champagne from a biodynamic producer who's been doing it since the 1970s β€” this is the kind of bottle that costs a fraction of what a big house would charge for less interesting juice. Demi-Sec gets dismissed as 'sweet' by people who've never tried a good one. Don't be that person.

πŸ’ŽHidden Gem

Rare Wine Company Boston Bual Madeira

Madeira is one of the most food-friendly, age-worthy, and underappreciated wines on earth β€” and almost nobody orders it. The Boston Bual sits in the sweet spot between dry and rich, with an oxidative complexity that makes it genuinely exciting. Most tables will walk right past this and order a Barolo. Their loss.

β›”Skip This

Top-tier trophy bottles ($1,000+)

The ceiling on this list stretches to $7,000, and at a downtown bistro with steep baseline markups, the prestige bottles get hit hardest. If you want to flex, this isn't the room for it β€” the real value here is in the mid-range, not the stratosphere.

🍽️Perfect Pairing

AndrΓ© Beaufort Demi-Sec Champagne (Pinot Noir) + Burrata with salsa verde and anchovy

The Demi-Sec's subtle sweetness and high acidity cut through the fat of the burrata while the Pinot Noir base has enough body to hang with the anchovy's salt punch. It's a counterintuitive move that works exactly because this Champagne isn't trying to be brunch bubbles.

πŸ”₯ The Bottom Line

Estela is one of the few restaurants in New York where the wine list is genuinely worth your attention before you ever look at the food menu. The markups aren't gentle, but the curation is exceptional β€” send any serious wine drinker here without hesitation.

Comments

Cmd+Enter to post
Loading comments...

Sign In

or

No password needed β€” we'll email you a sign-in link.

Get the Weekly Wingman

One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.