Andolini's Pizzeria
Pizza joint with a surprisingly grown-up wine list
Multiple · Tulsa · Italian Pizzeria · Visit Website ↗
Reviewed April 1, 2026
Wingman Metrics
First Impression
You walk into a Tulsa pizza spot expecting a two-column wine list of generic house red and white, and instead you find Allegrini, Dr. Konstantin Frank, and a Sonoma Sauvignon Blanc sharing space with your garlic knots. It's not deep, but someone clearly gave a damn. The price ceiling of $72 a bottle at a casual pizza place says more about intent than most fine dining lists do.
Selection Deep Dive
The list is compact — maybe a dozen bottles in the research data — but the regional spread is smarter than it has any right to be at a pizzeria. You've got Italian representation via Allegrini (Veneto), a nod to Argentina with La Posta from Mendoza, California covered across Sauvignon Blanc, Cab, and Merlot, and even a Dr. Konstantin Frank from the Finger Lakes throwing a curveball. The gaps are real — no Sangiovese, no Nebbiolo, nothing from Southern Italy — but what's here is chosen with intention rather than just punched in from a distributor catalog. It's a list that makes you curious rather than bored.
By the Glass
Eight pours by the glass is solid for a pizza joint, running from $7 to $13 — which means you can get a decent Allegrini Italian red for $12.50 without committing to a bottle. The low end ($7 Pinot Grigio) is what it is, but the top of the by-the-glass range earns its keep with the Dr. Konstantin Frank at $13 being a genuinely interesting pour you won't find at every restaurant in Tulsa.
Gen 5 Merlot — $36/bottle
California Merlot with a clean pedigree at a price that doesn't punish you for ordering pizza alongside it. The bottle-to-glass ratio checks out too — you're not getting gouged if you go bottle here.
Dr. Konstantin Frank
Most people walk past Finger Lakes wines on a list because they don't recognize the region. That's a mistake here — Frank is one of the most respected producers in New York, and $13 a glass for something this interesting at a pizza place is a genuine find.
Aperture Sauvignon Blanc
At $72 a bottle, this is a solid wine from a well-regarded Sonoma producer — but it's the ceiling of the list and feels like the one outlier priced for the rare table that wants to flex. For a pizza night, the math doesn't work. Put that $72 toward two bottles of something else on this list.
Allegrini Italian Red + The Clemenza Pizza
A Veneto red with The Godfather reference pizza is almost too on-brand, but it works. Allegrini has the acidity to cut through the cheese and the fruit weight to stand up to whatever's going on with the toppings. This is the move.
🎲 The Bottom Line
Andolini's doesn't have to try this hard on wine, and the fact that they do earns real respect. It's not a destination wine list, but it's absolutely the right list for a pizza place that takes itself seriously — and in Tulsa, that makes it a Wild Card worth knowing about.
Comments
Get the Weekly Wingman
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.