1909
Cooperstown's Clubby Steakhouse Hits California Hard
Cooperstown · Cooperstown · American, Steakhouse
Reviewed April 18, 2026
Wingman Metrics
First Impression
Walking into 1909 feels like stepping into a well-heeled supper club from another era — dim lighting, lake views, turn-of-the-century artwork on the walls. The wine list arrives and immediately tells you exactly what kind of place this is: California Cabernet country, full stop. It's a short conversation, but at least it's an honest one.
Selection Deep Dive
The list runs 100-150 bottles and reads like a greatest hits of California's most recognizable names — Caymus, Jordan, Silver Oak Alexander Valley, Stag's Leap, Duckhorn, Rombauer, Far Niente. There's nothing adventurous here, no detours through Burgundy or the Rhône, no surprises lurking in a back page. What it does, it does with conviction: if you're getting a steak in upstate New York and want a California Cab to match, this list has your back. Wine Spectator handed them an Award of Excellence in 2023 for exactly this kind of focused, well-curated program — not depth, but reliability within a lane.
By the Glass
Ten to sixteen pours by the glass, running $10–$18, which is a reasonable range for a resort-adjacent steakhouse in a tourist town. Expect the usual California suspects to anchor the list — Rombauer Chardonnay is almost certainly one of them. Rotation appears minimal; this is not a program that's swapping in seasonal surprises every few weeks.
Jordan Cabernet Sauvignon — $40–$60 estimated bottle range
Jordan consistently over-delivers for its price point — structured, food-friendly, and genuinely good with a steak without requiring you to drop the big dollars that Caymus or Far Niente command here.
Stag's Leap Wine Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon
Most tables are reaching for Caymus on autopilot. Stag's Leap is the smarter order — more finesse, better balance, and a name with actual Napa history behind it. It tends to get overlooked next to the louder brands on a list like this.
Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon
Caymus is fine wine in a vacuum, but it's also one of the most marked-up bottles in America's restaurant industry. You're paying for the name recognition more than the juice at this point, and there are better options on this very list.
Silver Oak Alexander Valley Cabernet Sauvignon + Dry-Aged New York Strip
Silver Oak Alexander Valley runs warmer and riper than its Napa counterpart — vanilla, dark fruit, soft tannins. That profile wraps around a dry-aged strip like it was made for it, complementing the beef's deep savory funk without competing with it.
✔️ The Bottom Line
1909 is a perfectly competent steakhouse wine list for a destination resort town — it does California Cabernet well, marks it up predictably, and doesn't try to be anything it's not. Send a friend here if they want a solid Cab with a great steak and a lake view; send them elsewhere if they want to be surprised.
Comments
Get the Weekly Wingman
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.