Nantucket

The Company of the Cauldron earns its Wine Spectator nod — this is a focused, fairly priced list that understands its audience and the food it's serving. Not the most adventurous wine program on the island, but on a candlelit night in Nantucket with lobster in front of you, it more than does the job.

Ship's Inn isn't a destination for wine obsessives, but it's a genuinely solid pick for a summer Nantucket dinner where you want something familiar and fairly priced alongside excellent seafood. Order the Riesling, get the scallops, and don't overthink it.